

May was struck in the back by a 106 mph line drive on Sep 22, pitching only 2 innings (36 pitches) before being removed. Back/side trauma can affect mechanics and pitch count even when medically cleared to start. The market moved from -191 to -163 but may not fully account for performance impact vs just availability. Mathews (3.65 ERA, 96 pitches last outing, 5 days rest) is healthy and well-rested.
The Cardinals have effectively punted their final games by sitting core veterans like Goldschmidt and Contreras to play prospects. The Brewers have a massive lineup advantage here.