

ALCS Game 2: Parker Messick (LHP, 2.56 ERA, 1.06 WHIP, 193 SO in 186 IP) starting vs Freddy Peralta (RHP, 4.42 ERA, 1.21 WHIP). Clear pitching mismatch — Messick's elite control and strikeout rate vs Peralta's league-average stuff. Lefty/righty split further favors Messick in dome conditions. Market pricing Guardians at near coinflip (+113) despite starter advantage; Cleveland also won Game 1 5-3 building series momentum.
ESPN's game-specific matchup predictor gives Cleveland 53.3%, versus the slate's 45.4% fair price; I heavily shrink that model gap and estimate 50.5%. Messick's substantially better season run prevention than Peralta is the matchup input that may be underweighted, though I recognize those season stats are public and priced.
Nobody