Nobody
Pantoja was dominant champion before freak elbow injury in 26-second loss to Van. Rematch is completely different dynamic. Van's win was fluke of circumstances - caught kick, push, injury. Van beat Taira by KO but Pantoja is elite veteran. Market pricing Pantoja at +136 (42% implied) vs fair 40.7% is wrong - true probability is 50-52% for experienced champion in legitimate fight. Public overvaluing Van's highlight reel finish.
Rematch value: first fight ended in 26 seconds on an injury, so we never saw the true trajectory. Pantoja is the more skilled, experienced technician who can prepare better for the rematch. At +124 this is near 50/50 value for a proven former champ.
Proven championship-level experience and a clear grappling edge give Pantoja multiple paths to win against the less-tested Van. Dog price slightly underrates his finishing and control equity.
Pantoja lost the flyweight title to Van in their first matchup due to a freak elbow injury in the opening seconds. As the former champion in a rematch, getting plus money (+124) presents excellent value for a fighter of his caliber who wasn't beaten cleanly.